A shortfall is a deemed dividend only up to the company's distributable surplus (s109Y). Enter the company's figures at 30 June.
Is this just retained earnings?
Roughly, and it's a useful first estimate, but it isn't the same thing. Net assets less paid-up capital is total equity less share capital, which is retained earnings plus reserves. Section 109Y(2) then adjusts it:
| Item | Compared with retained earnings |
| Reserves, e.g. an asset revaluation reserve | Higher. Included, so unrealised revaluation gains can support a deemed dividend. |
| Provisions that aren't present legal obligations, e.g. deferred tax liability, warranty or restructuring provisions | Higher. Not counted as liabilities. Only present legal obligations and provisions for depreciation, annual and long service leave, and amortisation of IP and trade marks reduce net assets. |
| The year's income tax payable and unpaid PAYG instalments at 30 June (TD 2012/10) | Lower. They count as liabilities. If the accounts don't book the current year's tax, deduct it. |
| Division 7A amounts: payments (s109C) and forgiven debts (s109F) this year | Higher. Added back: the money has already left the company and reduced equity. |
| Non-commercial loans: amounts deemed dividends in earlier years (s109D, s109E, former s108) still shown as assets | Lower. Deducted, because they've already been taxed. |
| Repayments of non-commercial loans during the year | Lower. Deducted. |
| Dividends declared by 30 June but not yet paid | Lower. They're a liability. |
| Commissioner's discretion | The Commissioner can substitute a value if assets or provisions are significantly over- or undervalued. |
Example. Share capital $100, retained earnings $80,000, asset revaluation reserve $50,000, deferred tax liability $15,000, and old s109D loans of $20,000 still shown as a receivable. Retained earnings is $80,000, but the distributable surplus is net assets $130,100 + deferred tax liability $15,000 − paid-up capital $100 − non-commercial loans $20,000 = $125,000.
So a company with accumulated losses can still have a surplus if it has revalued property or holds provisions that aren't legal obligations. And one with healthy retained earnings can have a much smaller surplus if it carries old deemed-dividend loans or hasn't booked the year's tax. Use retained earnings as a sense check, and enter the six figures above.